I feel old...
Oh my god, I really can't believe this album is 25 years old!! (This blog is only six years its junior.)
What a nice birthday gift – an uncommonly excellent covers collection!
Maybe I will always slightly prefer the rawer Call the Doctor, and in certain moods the wearier One Beat, but this in retrospect is unmistakably the S-K album, most of all for the serendipitous addition of Janet, perfecting their signature aesthetic, and also for the last unequivocal gasp of a boundless, youthful energy that sounds like lightning in a bottle. As Robert Christgau very aptly put it at the time, "One reason you know they're young is that they obviously believe they can rock and roll at this pitch forever." Then three years later, Greil Marcus named them America's best rock band. He was right about that, and I'd go one further to say that, for my money anyway, the Corin-Carrie-Janet S-K were the best US rock group ever, period. Emphasis on group. Words and guitar. And guitar. And drums! (The last record sans Janet just wasn't the same, sadly.) Dig Me Out was where all of that really came together, taking on its electrifying adamantine form, shining and sharpening Call the Doctor's murkier, rougher edges and propelling its upfront duo into a kind of sonic bliss in aporetic tension with the anxious drama of their voices, words, half-articulated doubts and desires.
Accordingly everyone's on their A-game here to pay proper tribute: all good, most very good, a few great in their own right. Of particular note: Wilco's wonderful cover is a good reminder that "One More Hour" is one of the best love songs ever written. Husband and wife Jason Isbell and Amanda Shires play "Not What You Want" like it's an outlaw anthem. And Black Belt Eagle Scout's simmering, sultry take on "It's Enough" – Dig Me In's overall standout track, despite being only the sixth- or seventh-best song on Dig Me Out – fortunately led me to her two terrific LPs, some of the best new music I'd neglected to hear while relistening ad infinitum to my favourite albums of yesteryear (or covers thereof). You know, like old people do.