VIFF, pt. 3: Masters and Disciples
Ash Is Purest White Here, Jia Zhangke is performing his greatest hits--a little
Xiao Wu, several cuts off
Platform and
Unknown Pleasures, lots of
Still Life, a touch of
A Touch of Sin--while continuing to survey the uneven patterns of "progress" and change in China's recent history. As usual, Jia is particularly concerned with what exactly it means for ordinary people to live through such epochal social, economic, and cultural changes. Where
Platform followed its characters, in Jia's native province of Shanxi, from 1979 to the early 1990s,
Ash Is Purest White opens in 2001 and concludes in the present, beginning and ending in Datong, the Shanxi industrial city where
Unknown Pleasures took place; the new film's middle section is set in Fengjie, along the monumental Three Gorges Dam, which was the setting for
Still Life and its companion documentary,
Dong. Jia fuses these familiar settings, elements, and themes into something new within his oeuvre, namely his most humane and empathetic film. A friend observed that it's both Jia's least formalist narrative feature and his most emotionally moving work. This is precisely on-point, and within this less formally rigorous context, Jia's muse, Zhao Tao, gives her best performance to date; her co-star, Liao Fan, is nearly as impressive.
Three Faces Similarly drawing from earlier works in a truly fruitful manner, Jafar Panahi's latest not-a-film is his most Kiarostamian, pre- or post-"ban." Indeed, this must be a conscious homage to the late Iranian master: obscuring boundaries between documentary and fiction in both its premise and execution,
Three Faces evokes, most of all,
Life, and Nothing More and
The Wind Will Carry Us (two of my personal favorites among Kiarostami's
oeuvre). Yet in its focus on two would-be artists prevented from practising their art (three if one counts Panahi himself), and specifically on the constraints circumscribing the lives and careers of women (in contrast to the director, who has clearly found clever ways around his punitive sentence), this is also quintessential Panahi.
Lush Reeds Yang Yishu's film never fully settles on what type of movie it is--social commentary? investigative-journalism thriller? domestic drama? dreamy mood piece?--and it's this ambiguous, shifting quality that ultimately make it something really special and exciting. In a post-screening Q&A, Yang noted that her film's Chinese title and its structure are drawn from the classical
Book of Songs, which may account for its stately rhythms and elliptical form, but not necessarily (to my knowledge, at least) its pervasive sense of mystery. The less said about plot specifics, the better--see it, by all means. Unhurried and quiet (in a rather ghostly way), it's a knockout.
The Eyes of Orson Welles I never grew tired of
watching this documentary, jam-packed with film clips, archival footage, drawings, and paintings by Welles, just as I never tire of revisiting most Welles films, but I did tire of
listening to Mark Cousins' ponderous voice-over, jam-packed with annoying rhetorical questions, on-the-nose jokes, and interesting stray observations framed as revelatory insights, as well to the treacly, repetitive score that Cousins lays over virtually the whole film. Admittedly, some of the connections that Cousins suggests--particularly between Welles's many surviving drawings and his distinctive film style--are remarkable and persuasive, but these points could've been delivered more effectively (and less irritatingly) in a conventional documentary format, rather than as an indulgent epistolary essay addressed, presumptuously, to "Orson."